Cultural journalism is not simply about reporting on works, artists, exhibitions or events. It also produces frames of interpretation. By choosing an angle, references, categories, sources and vocabulary, it helps shape how cultural practices become understandable in the public sphere.
This function becomes particularly apparent when the subjects being examined circulate across different territories, languages or institutional environments. A work produced in Kinshasa and presented in Berlin, an artist working between Dakar and Paris, a festival bringing together several musical scenes or a diasporic cultural initiative cannot always be explained through a single national framework.
The journalistic challenge is therefore no longer limited to documenting the cultural subject itself. It also involves contextualising the different environments through which it moves.
From this perspective, an intercultural approach can be useful: not as a new branch intended to replace cultural journalism, but as an additional editorial requirement when cultural realities circulate between several systems of reference.
Cultural journalism already performs mediation
Cultural journalism has historically occupied a particular position between artistic production and the public sphere. It provides information about works and events, performs a critical function, offers context and selects what deserves editorial attention. In doing so, it proposes categories through which audiences can situate the cultural practices being discussed.
This function extends beyond the simple transmission of information. When a journalist explains why a work matters, places an artist within a particular history or draws connections between different practices, a form of mediation is already taking place.
Cultural journalism therefore does more than communicate culture. It also helps organise the conditions under which culture becomes intelligible.
This function remains relevant in contemporary media environments. What changes are the contexts in which such mediation must take place.
When cultural objects move across contexts
A particular difficulty arises when cultural practices circulate. Consider a work produced in one context and subsequently presented in another. The references surrounding it in its place of origin may not be available to its new audience.
A term may have a specific local meaning. A practice may refer to a political or social history that is unfamiliar elsewhere, while an artistic form may be interpreted differently depending on the institutions presenting it.
Journalistic work must then go beyond describing the subject. It must reconstruct part of the context necessary to understand it.
This may sound straightforward, but it is not.
Contextualising involves deciding what needs to be explained, what can remain implicit and which references will help readers understand a practice without reducing it to an immediately familiar category.
The risk of translating the unfamiliar through the familiar
When journalists work with a context unfamiliar to their audience, a natural temptation arises: to explain the unfamiliar through categories that are already known. This approach can make a subject easier to understand, but it also carries risks.
An artistic scene may be described as the “African equivalent” of a European or North American phenomenon. A musical genre may be presented primarily through its similarities to a more familiar genre, while a local institution may be assigned a Western category that corresponds only partially to how it actually operates.
The information becomes more accessible, but at the cost of reducing the context.
Journalistic mediation must therefore find a balance. Establishing points of comparison can be useful; turning them into systematic equivalences can, conversely, prevent readers from understanding what makes the situation distinctive.
Contextualising rather than culturalising
This difficulty leads to an important distinction: working across contexts does not mean explaining every difference through “culture”.
A disagreement between two institutions may arise from their funding arrangements. A difficulty in cooperation may relate to administrative regulations, while differences in working conditions may result from unequal economic resources. Tensions surrounding a project may also be connected to an institution’s political history.
Immediately describing such situations as “cultural differences” can obscure their concrete causes.
A rigorous intercultural approach does not therefore consist in searching for cultural oppositions everywhere. On the contrary, it seeks to distinguish what genuinely relates to systems of reference or social practices from what is shaped by institutions, language, resources or power relations.
Context becomes more important than the label.
Language is never merely a channel
This question becomes even more apparent in multilingual journalistic work.
An interview may be conducted in one language and published in another. A press release may be written in French while the project takes place primarily in a German-speaking environment. An artist may use a concept drawn from a language for which the publication’s language offers no exact equivalent.
The journalist must then translate. But translation also involves interpretation.
Which term should be retained? What needs to be explained? When should the original word remain untranslated? What might be lost in a translation that reads too smoothly?
Journalistic work here approaches the practice of linguistic mediation.
Faithfulness does not always mean producing the most literal sentence. It may require reconstructing enough context for readers to understand the function of a term within its original environment.
The interview as an encounter between frames of reference
The interview is another setting in which these questions arise. Journalists approach a conversation with their own categories, while the person being interviewed has theirs. The encounter between the two can reveal a discrepancy.
A question that seems obvious within one journalistic environment may make little sense in another. An interviewee may also reject the categories through which the journalist attempts to present their work.
Such moments do not necessarily need to be treated as obstacles. They can themselves become sources of information.
When an artist challenges the way their work is described, that challenge reveals something about the categories in circulation. When an institution uses vocabulary different from what the journalist expected, the discrepancy may expose differences between professional or institutional contexts.
Attentive journalism therefore does not merely seek answers. It also examines the categories through which questions and answers become possible.
Who decides which context matters?
Contextualising does not mean accumulating information indefinitely. Every publication requires selection, and journalists must decide which elements are necessary for understanding the subject.
That decision is already an editorial one.
In an article about an African artist exhibiting in Europe, should the story begin with the artist’s country of origin, artistic practice, professional trajectory, the institution presenting the exhibition or the conditions of the art market?
The choice of starting point changes the narrative.
For example, systematically introducing African artists through their geographical origins while presenting others primarily through their aesthetics or artistic approach produces a difference in framing.
Contextualisation must therefore itself be questioned. Not every available piece of context is relevant simply because it can be included.
Avoiding the role of spokesperson
Transnational subjects also carry another risk: turning an individual into a representative of a much larger group.
An artist may become “the voice of a generation”, a curator may be presented as someone who explains “the African art scene”, and a writer may be interviewed as a spokesperson for an entire diaspora.
These shortcuts make stories easier to construct. They also place a burden of representation on people who may never have claimed such a role.
Individual testimony remains a situated perspective. It can illuminate a broader dynamic, but it is not sufficient to represent that dynamic in its entirety.
Journalistic care therefore involves distinguishing what a source says about their own experience from what can legitimately be generalised from it.
International circulation also reshapes sources
Transnational journalism also requires reflection on where information comes from.
Institutions with well-developed communication departments generally make press releases, photographs, biographies, press kits and professional contacts more readily available. As a result, they become easier to cover.
By contrast, an organisation with fewer resources may have very little accessible documentation, even when its cultural activity is significant. This practical difference influences editorial coverage.
Journalists consequently risk focusing more heavily on subjects that are already well documented. The availability of sources becomes an invisible infrastructure of visibility.
A more attentive approach may therefore require looking beyond immediately available materials: contacting cultural actors directly, consulting local media, comparing different accounts or searching through less accessible archives.
Working with local sources
Local sources become particularly important when a subject concerns a context with which the journalist has limited familiarity.
Local media, researchers, artists, institutions, associations and professionals working within the territory may provide information that international sources overlook. They also make it possible to compare categories used from the outside with those circulating within the context itself.
This does not mean that a local source is automatically more objective or legitimate. Local sources also speak from particular positions.
The value lies in bringing different perspectives together. A more precise understanding can emerge when several kinds of sources are placed in relation to one another rather than when a single narrative is reproduced.
Europe–Africa: moving beyond the logic of two blocs
These questions are particularly important in cultural narratives connecting Europe and Africa.
The expression itself is convenient: it identifies a space of relations. Yet it also carries a risk, namely presenting two continents as homogeneous cultural entities entering into dialogue.
The realities are considerably more complex.
A project between Freiburg and Kinshasa does not involve the same histories and institutions as cooperation between Lisbon and Maputo or between Paris and Dakar. Languages, cultural policies, professional networks, colonial histories and available resources differ significantly.
Journalistic work must therefore be able to use the category Europe–Africa without treating it as an explanation in itself.
It identifies a geography of relations. It does not yet explain the nature of those relations.
Diasporas shift the boundaries even further
Diasporic trajectories make national frameworks even less sufficient.
Someone may live in Germany, work with Congolese institutions, publish in French and participate in both European and African professional networks. To which space does their activity belong?
The question itself may be poorly framed.
Some cultural practices are constructed precisely through movement between several spaces. Presenting them exclusively through national origin can therefore obscure an essential part of how they function.
Cultural journalism in transnational contexts must be capable of observing these trajectories without systematically attempting to assign them to a single territory.
Mobility then becomes not an exception requiring explanation, but a characteristic of the subject being studied.
Digital access does not remove the need for context
Digital platforms provide access to substantial amounts of information originating from different territories. A work, performance or controversy can become visible across distances almost immediately.
This accessibility can create the impression that context is equally available. That is not necessarily the case.
Watching a video does not mean knowing the conditions under which it was produced. Reading a social media post does not always make it possible to understand the debate to which it responds. Access to automatic translation does not guarantee that cultural or institutional references have been accurately conveyed.
The faster content circulates, the more necessary contextualisation may become.
The availability of information does not replace its interpretation.
A professional stance rather than a separate specialism
This is where the idea of an intercultural perspective becomes useful.
It does not necessarily need to designate a new field of journalism separate from cultural journalism. It can instead describe a professional stance.
Such a stance recognises that the meaning of a subject may vary between contexts. It pays attention to languages, examines categories, distinguishes cultural differences from institutional or economic ones and draws on a wider range of sources.
It also avoids turning individual experiences into collective representations. Finally, it seeks to make a context understandable without claiming to capture it exhaustively.
These requirements can apply to cultural journalism, but they are equally relevant to other areas of journalism.
Shifting the frame without abandoning criticism
Openness to multiple contexts must not, however, lead to such excessive caution that meaningful analysis becomes impossible. Journalism retains a critical function.
Contextualising does not mean abandoning the evaluation of a cultural policy, institution, exhibition or programme. It means grounding that evaluation in sufficiently situated information.
Similarly, recognising a plurality of perspectives does not mean that every interpretation is equally valid.
Claims can be verified, sources compared, inconsistencies identified and power relations documented.
Shifting the frame of interpretation does not therefore replace journalistic rigour. It expands its scope.
Conclusion
Cultural journalism and an intercultural perspective are not necessarily two opposing forms of journalism. They address different dimensions of editorial work.
The former covers, critiques and contextualises cultural practices. The latter becomes particularly useful when that contextualisation must connect several languages, territories, institutional systems or frames of reference.
In increasingly transnational cultural environments, the essential competence is therefore not simply to know the works being discussed. It also involves understanding the conditions under which their meanings change as they circulate.
Translate without reducing. Contextualise without confining. Compare without creating false equivalences. Examine differences without explaining everything through culture.
Perhaps this is where the contemporary shift in cultural journalism lies: not in the emergence of a new specialism intended to replace the existing one, but in the expansion of the interpretive frameworks needed to describe practices that can no longer always be understood from a single point of view.


